Recipe
🍳 BREAKFAST
Boiled Fish and Johnny Cake
A light, limey grouper broth with potatoes and onion, served with a slab of sweet Bahamian johnny cake for dunking, a true island breakfast.
Bahamian · medium · serves 4
prep 15 min · cook 30 min
~609 cal · 41g protein · 82g carbs · 12g fat · 5g fiber · 15g sugars · 7g sat fat (estimated, per serving)
↓ Jump to Recipe
AI-generated illustration
Boiled fish and johnny cake is a true Bahamian breakfast, a light, bright fish broth paired with a slab of sweet island bread. It is a traditional morning dish, valued as a comforting, restorative start to the day.
Firm white fish, often grouper, is gently poached with potatoes, onion, and a good hit of lime and bird pepper into a clean, limey broth, quite different from the dark stew fish also loved in the islands. Alongside comes johnny cake, a dense, slightly sweet Bahamian quick bread.
The bread is torn and dunked into the tangy broth, soaking up its brightness. Boiled fish and johnny cake is honest, sustaining island food, the taste of a Bahamian morning by the sea.
Saved recipes and passport stamps are kept on this device. Sign in to keep them across your devices and leave reviews.
Make it yours
✓ Naturally nut-, egg- and pork-free. No swaps needed.
Toggle a diet and the ingredients rewrite themselves with regional substitutes.
🥕 Vegetarian
🌱 Vegan
🌾 Gluten-Free
🥛 Dairy-Free
🥜 Nut-Free
🥚 Egg-Free
🐖 Pork-Free
Dietary labels are a cooking guide, not allergen-safety advice. We track dairy, egg, gluten, tree nuts and peanuts (we count coconut as a tree nut, following FDA labeling), fish, and shellfish; we do not screen for sesame, soy, mustard, celery, or sulphites. If you have a food allergy, read the label on every product you use, and note that a kitchen can cross-contaminate in ways a recipe cannot control.
Ingredients
US
Metric
Serves 4
1.5 lbs firm white fish (grouper), in chunks
2 potatoes
1 onion
2 lime
1 bird pepper
2 cups flour (for the johnny cake)
3 tbsp sugar
2 tsp baking powder
3 tbsp butter (for the johnny cake)
3/4 cup milk (for the johnny cake)
to taste salt
to taste black pepper
Instructions
1
Simmer the onion, potato, lime juice, and bird pepper in salted water until the potatoes are nearly tender.
2
Add the fish and poach gently for about 8 minutes, until just cooked and the broth is bright and limey.
✎ Chef’s note
Poach the fish gently rather than boiling it hard, so it stays in whole, tender flakes instead of breaking apart in the broth.
3
For the johnny cake, rub the butter into the flour, sugar, baking powder, and salt, then mix in the milk to a soft dough.
4
Bake or griddle the johnny cakes until golden and cooked through.
5
Serve bowls of the boiled fish with thick slices of johnny cake for dunking.
Bahamian island breakfast tradition.
Ratings & reviews
Cooked it? Rate this dish:
No account needed. Sign in to leave a full review with a comment.
Cooked it?
Kept on this device, no account needed. Sign in to leave a review and keep your passport across your devices.
No reviews yet, be the first to cook it.
🌏 While it simmers, know your destination
📍
Nassau. Guava duff takes about three hours. A sheet of dough is spread with guava, rolled and steamed in a cloth until it sets, then sliced and served under a butter and egg sauce usually spiked with rum. Peas and rice, made with pigeon peas, is the standard side and is a different dish from peas and grits.
🗺️
Bahamas. Conch is regulated rather than endless. The fishery has a closed season and size rules because stocks have fallen across the region, which is worth knowing before ordering it three ways in one meal. Cracked conch is pounded, battered and fried; the salad is raw, diced and cured in lime and sour orange at the counter in front of you.
🌍
North America. Almost every regional cooking here records who arrived and on what terms. Enslaved West Africans brought rice, okra, black-eyed peas and the techniques behind Lowcountry and Creole food; Chinese railway labour and later Italian, Jewish, Mexican and Vietnamese arrivals built the way the cities eat; and Indigenous foodways sit underneath all of it.
The story behind this dish is up top, worth a read while the pot works.
More from Bahamas
Bahamian Stew FishFish simmered in a dark browned-flour gravy with tomato, thyme, and lime, a Bahamian breakfast-to-dinner staple.
Bahamian Conch SaladFresh conch diced and cured at the table in lime and sour orange with sweet peppers, tomato, cucumber, and fiery goat pepper.
Guava DuffA boiled sweet dough rolled around ribbons of ripe guava, sliced into spirals and drowned in a warm rum-butter sauce.
Browse all Bahamas recipes →
Good to know
You’ll need: Griddle or flat pan, Oven.
Storing it: Soup keeps 3 to 4 days refrigerated and freezes well. Reheat gently and loosen with a little water or stock if needed.
Make it a Bahamas meal
Sky JuiceDrink
Guava DuffDessert
Similar dishes from around the world
MohingaMyanmar
EncebolladoEcuador
PepesupEquatorial Guinea
Grenadian Fish BrothGrenada
GarudhiyaMaldives
Vincentian Fish BlaffSaint Vincent and the Grenadines
Cuisine
Diet
Frequently asked questions
What is Boiled Fish and Johnny Cake?
A light, limey grouper broth with potatoes and onion, served with a slab of sweet Bahamian johnny cake for dunking, a true island breakfast.
Where does Boiled Fish and Johnny Cake come from?
Boiled Fish and Johnny Cake is a Bahamian dish from Nassau, Bahamas.
Can Boiled Fish and Johnny Cake be made vegan, gluten-free, or dairy-free?
This Boiled Fish and Johnny Cake recipe includes substitution suggestions for vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, nut-free, egg-free, and pork-free versions, including several at once such as gluten-free and dairy-free together. Treat them as a starting guide rather than a guarantee, and see the allergen note below.
Is Boiled Fish and Johnny Cake safe for people with food allergies?
Our dietary labels and substitutions are a cooking guide, not medical or allergen-safety advice. We track dairy, egg, gluten, tree nuts and peanuts (we count coconut as a tree nut, following FDA labeling), fish, and shellfish, but we do not screen for sesame, soy, mustard, celery, or sulphites. If you have a food allergy, always read the label on every product you use, and remember a home or commercial kitchen can cross-contaminate ingredients in ways a recipe cannot control.
How long does Boiled Fish and Johnny Cake take to make?
About 45 minutes total (15 minutes prep, 30 minutes cooking), serving 4.
Get the Sunday Spin
One dish from somewhere in the world, in your inbox every Sunday. No spam, just dinner inspiration you can cook that day.